How to Choose an SEO Company

How to Choose an SEO Company

Are you looking to improve your online presence and drive more organic traffic to your website? Hiring a reliable SEO company can be a game-changer. But with so many options out there, how do you choose the right one?

We break down the steps to finding the perfect SEO company for your business. From understanding the basics of SEO to evaluating potential companies and finalizing your selection, we’ve got you covered.

SEO Basics

Search engine optimization (SEO) refers to strategies and techniques for increasing a website’s rankings in search engine results pages (SERPs). The higher a site ranks for relevant keywords, the more visible it is to searchers and the more traffic it can drive.

Figure out if you need SEO or SEM.

SEO for Digital Marketing

SEO for digital marketing increases organic search traffic by optimizing content and web pages for search engines like Google, websites can earn high rankings and gain visibility without paying for ads.

Strong SEO helps businesses connect with customers searching for related products or services online. It establishes authority and trust in search engines so a brand shows up when users want what that company offers.

Read our guide on how to start a business in Oregon.

Evaluating SEO Companies

When evaluating SEO companies, the first thing to look at is their reputation and years in business. An experienced company with a solid reputation has proven they can deliver effective SEO campaigns over many years.

Factors to consider:

  • Reputation and Years in Business: Look for an SEO company with 5+ years of experience, happy clients, and expertise tailored to your business and goals.
  • Case Studies and Success Stories: Review case studies and success stories that demonstrate tangible results, such as increased organic traffic, website sales, and ROI.
  • Assessment of the Agency’s SEO Strategies: Ensure the agency evaluates your website, assesses your goals, and outlines effective tactics leveraging proven best practices.

By evaluating these factors, you can gain confidence in an SEO company’s ability to meet your goals and drive long-term success.

Our San Jose SEO services.

Finalizing your SEO Company Selection

After careful evaluation, finalizing your SEO company selection should involve reviewing their track record and ensuring their strategies align with your goals.

Steps to take when making your final decision:

  • Asking the Right Questions: Before signing a contract, ask targeted questions about their experience, strategies, past results, communication practices, and unique value to evaluate if they understand your goals and have the expertise to execute effectively.
  • Reviewing the Contract Carefully: Scrutinize the contract details, including scope of work, fees, contract length, performance metrics, content ownership, guarantees, and assurances of white hat techniques, to avoid misaligned expectations.
  • Planning for Long-term SEO Success: Set milestones to track meaningful progress, designate a budget for continuous optimization, create fresh content regularly, focus on best practices over shortcuts, and prioritize user experience above all else.

By thoroughly vetting the SEO company, carefully reviewing the contract, and planning for long-term success, you can select a partner that will work closely with you to formulate a scalable, future-proof strategy and help solidify an enduring online presence for your business.

Our San Francisco SEO services.

Red Flags to Be Aware Of When Choosing an SEO Company

When selecting an SEO company, be wary of those that promise immediate rankings, guarantee specific positions, or lack transparency in their methods and reporting.

Red flags to watch out for:

  • Unrealistic Promises and Guarantees: Be very wary of any agency that promises you’ll be #1 in Google within a few months. An ethical SEO agency will set realistic goals tailored to your niche, budget, and site capabilities.
  • Lack of Transparency in Strategies and Reporting: SEO tactics and recommendations should be clearly explained. Lack of openness around strategies or campaign progress may indicate they have something to hide or lack expertise.
  • Low Pricing: Exceptionally cheap deals likely mean poor or offshore labor and ineffective tactics. Reasonable pricing paired with a proven process is key for long term success.

Avoid partnering with agencies that may use ineffective or unethical practices that could ultimately harm your online presence.

Our Seattle SEO services.

download 6

Identifying Your SEO Needs

Successful SEO requires defining goals, evaluating existing strategies, and understanding your audience to determine the most effective approach.

Steps to improve search results:

  1. Setting Your SEO Goals: Identify specific objectives and key performance indicators to track progress and refine strategies.
  2. Analyzing Your Current SEO Strategy: Assess current website visibility and performance, conduct technical audits, and perform content audits to guide improvements.

By identifying your SEO needs, setting clear goals, and analyzing your current strategy, you can develop a targeted approach to improve your search engine rankings, drive qualified traffic, and achieve your business objectives.

Our Portland SEO services.

Top SEO Practices for Success

Some best practices for effective SEO include optimizing pages for relevant keywords, creating quality content, improving website performance, structuring sites for crawlability, and building reputable backlinks.

Search engine algorithms constantly evolve, so SEO requires ongoing efforts:

  • Keyword Research: Optimize pages for terms and phrases users search for.
  • Quality Content: Create content that answers searchers’ queries.
  • Website Performance: Improve speed and performance for positive user experience.
  • Site Structure: Make pages easily crawlable for search engine robots.
  • Backlink Building: Acquire reputable links from other domains to boost rankings.

Elements like meta tags, alt text, site architecture, security, and mobile optimization also impact search visibility.

Visit our service page.

SEO Search Engine Ranking Results

SEO tactics signal relevance and authority to search engines, allowing compliant websites to earn high rankings without paying for advertising. By appropriately using targeted keywords in content and optimizing code, SEO helps web pages perform better in search results.

How SEO can benefit your website:

  • Increased Visibility: Pages with the best rankings drive the most referral traffic from search engines like Google and Bing. Over 90% of searchers don’t go past the first page of Google, making first-page rankings extremely valuable for attracting potential customers.
  • Higher Click-Through Rates: The higher the content ranks in search results, the more clicks, visitors, leads, and customers it earns as part of marketing strategies. Top-ranking pages often experience significantly higher click-through rates compared to lower-ranking pages.
  • Cost-Effective Marketing: Unlike paid advertising, SEO provides a cost-effective way to drive targeted traffic to your website. Once you achieve high rankings for relevant keywords, you can maintain a steady flow of organic traffic without continuously paying for each click.
  • Long-Term Benefits: While SEO requires ongoing efforts to maintain rankings, the results can be long-lasting. As you build authority and relevance in your industry, it becomes easier to rank for new keywords and maintain your search engine positions over time.
  • Competitive Advantage: By investing in SEO, you can gain a competitive edge over businesses that rely solely on paid advertising or neglect search optimization altogether. Outranking your competitors in search results can lead to increased market share and customer acquisition.

SEO is a powerful tool for driving targeted, organic traffic to your website and achieving your digital marketing goals. By focusing on relevance, authority, and user experience, you can improve your search engine rankings and attract more qualified leads and customers to your business.

About Helium SEO: Your Trusted Partner in Digital Success

At Helium SEO, we understand that choosing the right SEO company is crucial for your business’s online success. With over a decade of experience in the digital marketing industry, our team of skilled professionals is dedicated to helping you navigate the complex world of SEO and achieve your goals.

We believe that the key to selecting an SEO company lies in finding a partner that takes the time to understand your unique needs, develops customized strategies, and delivers measurable results.

Our complete range of services, including national and international SEO campaigns, geo-targeted efforts, conversion rate optimization, and Google Ads/PPC marketing, is designed to help your business thrive in the competitive digital space. By staying up-to-date with the latest industry trends and best practices, we continuously refine our techniques to deliver cutting-edge solutions that maximize your ROI.

When you choose Helium SEO as your partner, you gain access to a team of passionate, dedicated professionals who are committed to your success. We pride ourselves on our ability to develop long-lasting relationships with our clients, built on a foundation of trust, integrity, and exceptional results.

Contact us today to experience the Helium SEO difference and take your online presence to new heights.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

How do I find the right SEO agency?

Finding the right SEO agency involves meticulous research and analysis. Start by defining your goals and what services you need, such as website optimization, content creation, or link building.

Look for agencies with experience and success stories in your industry, and don’t forget to read reviews and ask for case studies. Prioritize transparency, asking potential agencies about their strategies, tools, and how they measure success.

How do I choose SEO services?

Choosing SEO services requires evaluating the provider’s expertise, reputation, and understanding of your industry. Look for agencies or professionals with proven success stories, transparent communication, and a tailored approach to meet your specific needs.

It’s important to assess their strategy for keyword research, content optimization, technical SEO, and adherence to Google’s guidelines to ensure long-term, organic growth.

How to choose a local SEO company?

When choosing a local SEO company, consider their experience and track record in improving local search rankings for businesses similar to yours. Look for a company with positive reviews and case studies demonstrating their success in generating local visibility.

They should offer a transparent strategy tailored to your business needs, including keyword optimization, local listings, and reputation management services, and that they communicate effectively regarding progress and results.

Alexia Dolan
Alexia Dolan
Alexia is a Content Writer at Helium SEO, holding a bachelor's degree in Journalism with a minor in Psychology from the University of Cincinnati. With a background in local news reporting and social media management for local franchises and production firms, Alexia brings a diverse skill set to her role. When she's not crafting compelling content, you can find her exploring nature with her dogs and staying up-to-date on the latest trends in pet nutrition.


Article Contents:

Article Contents:

Share This Article:

Get monthly insights on SEO, SEM, and CRO that drive results:

Discover Strategies We Use to Increase Client Traffic 9,000%

Get monthly insights on SEO, SEM, and CRO that drive results.

Get monthly articles on SEO, SEM, and CRO tips and insights from our team.

Ask us anything

Want an Audit from an SEO Professional?

Need help developing an overall digital marketing strategy or developing a specific plan for SEO or PPC. Fill out the details to the right, and an SEO professional will contact you to help you understand what SEO opportunities you have. 

Shopping Basket